Product Review
November 2018



This Product Review page is a limited distribution complimentary copy and not for distribution other than by the author.
Please consider subscribing to our monthly woodturning magazine.


Read a Free Sample Edition


Click ad to visit our sponsor


Negative Rake Scrapers

Made by Boxmaster Tools

Review by Mike Stafford

People that know me know there are two things in particular about woodturning that I truly love--turning boxes and new woodturning tools. So when I heard about some tools developed by an accomplished box turner I just had to see what they were all about.

Jimmie Allen is the owner of Boxmaster Tools ( and on the front page of his website is a sampling of his wonderful boxes. A friend, Willie Simmons, met Jimmie at the Portland AAW Symposium and because of that chance meeting Jimmie called me and we discussed box turning. One thing led to another and Jimmie sent me a few of his tools to try out.

You can see a sampling of his tool line that he sent for me to try in the title photo above.

The tools came with an 8” long handle with a 5/8” bore to accept both sizes of tools when using the available ½” reducer. Handles are available in 8-inch and 12-inch lengths with either a ½” or 5/8” bore. The unhandled tools (from top to bottom):

  • ¾” Long and Strong Curved Negative Rake Scraper
  • ½” Curved Negative Rake Scraper
  • ½” Lid and Tenon Tool
  • 5/8’ Curved Negative Rake Scraper
  • 5/8” Straight Sided, Flat Bottom Box Tool
  • 5/8” Round Nose Scraper
  • 5/8” Flare Tool
  • 5/8” Detail Tool

The observant viewer will notice that most of the tools are double-ended, providing extra versatility and value.  About half the length of these 10-inch unhandled tools can be inserted into the handle, which provides great stability.

The tools arrived with the cutting ends encased in a plastic material similar to that which is on new saw blades when purchased. Removing this coating revealed a razor-sharp edge.

You can see a closer view of the negative rake grinds in Photo 1.

Photo 1 - Negative rake grinds


By the way, the holes in the tool shafts are used during the tempering/hardening process. Jimmie states that by hanging the tools during the hardening process he has had no tools to warp (which can happen when tools are allowed to lay flat in the ovens). He uses the same hardening/tempering facilities as D-Way Tools of which he will take over ownership next year.

So How Do They Work?

After unpacking and giving them the once over, I was anxious to put steel to wood. And what kind of project should I turn to test Boxmaster Tools? It should be obvious that I would be trying them out on a box project. I mulled over various box designs I have turned and decided upon one which I thought would be best to give me a chance to use as many of the new tools as I could.

Let’s Begin With the Lid

I put a blank onto the lathe, rounded it up, and parted it into lid and body sections with the lid section still in the chuck. After hogging out a lot of the waste with a detail gouge, it was time to try out my first Boxmaster tool. The ½” Lid and Tenon tool is the tool of choice for cutting the interior lid mortise parallel and square. The long angled bevel on the left side and the narrow square cornered cutting tip makes it easy to plunge the scraper directly into the end grain and remove the waste, ending up with a square shoulder inside the lid (Photo 2).

Photo 2 - Cutting the lid mortise


Once the sides of the mortise were checked and proven parallel, it was time to shape the inside top area of the lid. I had planned on a dome shape for that surface. I decided to start shaping that area with the ½” right hand curved negative rake scraper. Ribbons of end grain wood chips poured off the razor sharp cutting edge (Photo 3 and Photo 4).

Photo 3 - Shaping the interior dome

Photo 4 - Ribbons of end grain


Once the basic dome shape was established, I switched to the ¾” Long and Strong Curved Negative Rake Scraper to refine the shape. The larger size and extra mass made it very easy to obtain a uniform curve on the inside of the lid (Photo 5).

Photo 5 - Refining the dome shape


That last step was to true up the bottom edge of the lid. I used the ½” Straight Skew on the opposite end of the ½” Lid and Tenon tool for that job. Doing so assured that the bottom of the lid was flat and in the same plane.

The end grain surfaces on the box lid were cut remarkably clean and required very little in the way of sanding, as seen in Photo 6.

Photo 6 - Cleanly cut end grain


Next: Turn the Body

After applying a little finish to the inside of the lid, I mounted the box body blank. I trued up the outside diameter and used the ½” Straight Skew to establish the body flange upon which the lid will fit. This razor sharp tool peeled off shavings cleanly (Photo 7).

Photo 7 - Cutting the body tenon


Once the tenon was sized so that the lid would just begin to fit, I quickly hollowed out the body of the box with a gouge. Then I switched to the 5/8’ Straight Sided, Flat Bottom Box Tool. This tool looks much like the ½” Lid and Tenon Tool but it has a slight radius on the left corner which allows the user to easily cut an eased corner without all the fuss and muss of a square corner, which can be tedious and hard to sand. In a stepwise fashion I pushed the long side of the tool’s cutting edge straight into the waste material and established a uniform depth (Photo 8). Once the depth was established all the way to the outside corner, it was just a matter of cleanly cutting the rest of the bottom flat (Photo 9). This was easily accomplished with the Flat Bottom Box Tool. Some sanding was necessary on the long grain but the end grain of the bottom was cut quite smooth and only needed some touch up sanding.

Photo 8 - Hollowing the box body

Photo 9 - Straight sides and flat bottom


On to the Outside of the Lid

Once the interior of the body was sanded and finished, the body tenon was adjusted so that the lid could be jam-fit onto the body. By doing so, the shape of the lid and body could be turned at the same time. I quickly turned off the waste on the body and established the basic dimensions and shape of the lid with a gouge.

After the diameter of the body was established, I used the 5/8” Round Nose Scraper to undercut the lid and blend the curve into the straight sides of the body (Photo 10).

Photo 10 - Blending the undercut lid to the body


Next, it was time to shape the top of the lid. I used the 5/8” Flare Tool for that operation. Its slight curve made it easy to cut the oriental shape I had in mind for the two steps of the box lid (Photo 11). The final cut surface almost did not need to be sanded (Photo 12).

Photo 11 - Shaping the lid

Photo 12 - The final cut surface of the lid


Finishing Up

After some sanding and application of finish, I reversed the body of the box and removed the tenon with a spindle gouge. I used the 5/8” Round Nose Scraper to dish out a recess on the bottom for a finished appearance.  A little sanding and some finish and my box was done (Photo 13 and Photo 14).  I didn’t use every tool in my Boxmaster Tool kit but I certainly used many of them.

Photo 13 - Finished box

Photo 14 - Open view


Final Thoughts

Early in my box turning days I used scrapers more than I currently do, but every box I turn has some operations that are best done with a scraper. Those operations and many others that I attempted with the Boxmaster Tools were all done well. Even when I was cutting a combination of side and end grain, like the curve on the underside of the lid, the cut was nearly flawless. The performance of these tools on end grain was exceptional.  Whenever you can cut the end grain of a dense timber so cleanly that it glistens with smoothness that is proof of an exceptional cut.  And best of all, that smoothness reduces the need for excessive sanding, which can cause heat checking in critical short end grain surfaces such as the bottom of a box or its lid.

Boxmaster Tools exceeded my expectations. They arrived beautifully finished and razor sharp. The handle is comfortable and retains enough mass to provide excellent control in use. The socket screws firmly lock the tools in place. The reducer functions well but I think I may purchase a separate ½” handle to avoid its use. You really can’t have enough tools or handles, right?

The variety of tool shapes offered by Boxmaster Tools opens up a lot of opportunities and solutions for turners to shape and clean up areas which might be difficult because of design. The long and strong curved negative rake scraper is a beast and will certainly have applications in other areas of turning, such as when smoothing curves on bowls or removing tear out. There is good value in the tools as most are double ended.  All in all I enjoyed using the Boxmaster Tools Jimmie Allen sent for me to test and they will be welcome additions to my woodturning arsenal.

For more information on the Boxmaster Tools, visit their web site by clicking here.